Fate of American hostages up in the air with little prospect of stalled hostage talks resuming soon

7 Min Read


The negotiations over the discharge of additional hostages from Gaza that broke down early Friday seem extremely unlikely to renew any time quickly, a number of senior administration officers informed CNN, leaving the destiny of a number of People believed to have been taken captive by Hamas up within the air.

The White Home has mentioned there may be one American girl and 7 males unaccounted for following Hamas’ October 7 assault on Israel. Thus far, 4 People have been launched because the begin of the warfare. All are believed to be twin Israeli-Americans.

The talks have stalled, and there does not appear to be any real prospects of these discussions beginning again up any time quickly, in line with a number of senior administration officers.

The foremost purpose for the deadlock remained unchanged as of Monday, in line with one senior administration official: Hamas is refusing to launch a remaining group of younger ladies hostages, and Israel won’t settle for the suggestion of shifting on to debate the following class of hostages: Males.

It additionally seems unlikely that the administration would be capable to negotiate individually for the discharge of People residents – just like what the Thai and Russian governments did for hostages from these nations. There isn’t a purpose to suppose that Hamas would do the US any “particular favor” in that method, mentioned a second senior administration official, who all however dismissed that risk.

Nationwide safety adviser Jake Sullivan mentioned Monday the US is doing “all the pieces in our energy” to get hostages launched from Hamas.

Regardless of the formal talks in Doha, Qatar, breaking down, Sullivan informed CNN that there are nonetheless “intensive discussions” between the US, Israel, Qatar and Egypt about “methods to finest get traction on a method that can get all of the hostages out – however in fact, for the USA, the paramount precedence is getting the American hostages out.”

On whether or not the White Home is considering a possible separate deal geared toward securing the discharge of twin Americans, Sullivan mentioned, “We’re speaking to the president about all of his choices by way of securing the discharge of American hostages.” However he declined to remark additional, citing “delicate diplomatic discussions behind closed doorways.”

Israel recalled its negotiators from Qatar – which was serving to facilitate talks between Israel and Hamas – on Saturday, blaming Hamas for failing to “fulfill its a part of the settlement, which included the return of all ladies and youngsters held hostage.” In a press release after negotiations ended, Hamas held Israel and the USA liable for ending the dialogue.

With preventing having resumed within the warfare, it stays unclear what – if something – may convey again a cessation in hostilities and revive hostage talks.

The Israel Protection Forces said it carried out greater than 400 strikes within the first 24 hours of renewed preventing Friday and, on Sunday, introduced it was expanding ground operations to all of Gaza. Greater than 15,800 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli assaults in Gaza since October 7, in line with the Hamas-controlled well being ministry within the enclave.

As CNN has beforehand reported, Israeli and US officers consider that Hamas is refusing to launch a lot of ladies within the 20- to 30-year-old age vary, lots of them taken from the Nova music competition, claiming that these ladies are thought-about troopers. That refusal, one official mentioned, is “completely unacceptable” on condition that there have been “credible allegations of sexual violence linked to Hamas and the October 7 atrocities.”

State Division spokesman Matt Miller mentioned Monday that one of many causes Hamas doesn’t need to launch ladies being held hostage appears to be as a result of “they don’t need these ladies to have the ability to speak about what occurred to them throughout their time in custody.” Nonetheless, he mentioned he couldn’t “communicate with a definitive evaluation” that this was a purpose Hamas was not releasing some hostages.

Israeli police are documenting circumstances of rape perpetrated towards ladies and women by members of Hamas because the militant group attacked Israel on October 7, killing 1,200 Israelis taking greater than 240 hostages.

“We’ve clearly seen the experiences that Hamas has dedicated sexual violence, they’ve dedicated rape, we’ve got no purpose in any respect to doubt these experiences,” Miller mentioned, including later, “actually there may be little or no that I’d put past Hamas with regards to its remedy of civilians, specifically its remedy of ladies.”

As a part of a deal that rose out of painstaking negotiations with the assistance of overseas mediation final month, Hamas launched 105 hostages over the seven days of truce, primarily ladies and youngsters. Israel in return launched 240 Palestinians – or about three for each girl and little one held in Gaza – additionally primarily women and youngsters, lots of whom have been detained in Israel however by no means charged.

The Israel Protection Forces mentioned Friday that there are 136 hostages nonetheless being held in Gaza, together with 17 ladies and youngsters. It’s unclear what number of of these are being held by Hamas versus different militant teams that function within the territory.

CNN’s Haley Britzky, Tamar Michaelis, Joshua Berlinger and Jack Forrest contributed to this report.

This story has been up to date with extra particulars.

Source link

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *